The Effectiveness of Exit Interviews in Reducing Employee Turnover
The prices of employee
turnover demonstrate that it costs businesses about one-fifth of an employee’s
salary to replace that worker. Indeed, it's expensive to replace employees
because of the productivity losses once somebody leaves employment, the prices
of hiring and training a new worker, and the slower productivity till the new
employee gets up to speed in their new job (Boushey & Glynn, 2012). In
keeping with the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, (2014) the annual
employee turnover rate for all areas of business in 2014 was around 43%. The
most talented and the productive workers are considered the stars that drive
the success of any organization and the failure to retain the same, in the
smaller organizations even can collapse/run when losing thousands of dollars, a
year within the form of knowledge and experience. United States Bureau of Labor
Statistics, (2014) further explains that in the case of huge organizations, the
price is even steeper costing millions of dollars. When characteristic the
apparent costs, the small, as well as large firms, are taking proactive steps
to reduce employee turnover and retain talented personnel. Workplace policies
and practices improve worker retention will facilitate companies to cut back
their turnover costs (Boushey & Glynn, 2012).
Fig. 1 TOP REASONS FOR EMPLOYEE TURNOVER
(United
States Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2014)
Fig.
2 UNDERSTANDING WHY YOUR EMPLOYEE IS LEAVING
(United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2014)
As per the above Fig. 1 six
reasons have been highlighted for employee turnover i.e. Lack of fit, Management
issues, no flexibility in working hours/condition, no job security, no career
advancement, no good pay/benefits. In Fig. 2 further illustrating reasons
for employee turnover, into that cultural misfit, failed expectations, no
coaching, organization instability, Poor working environment. Learning and
understanding why employees prefer to stay or leave the organization are
imperative to the success of any business and in several workplaces improving
employee retention to have key success (Zoltan & David, 1999). Several
organizations and talent auction specialists are utilizing exit interviews to
capture key information from workers as they leave the corporate, to prevent
employees from following their colleagues out the door, the organizations will
utilize the valuable information collected through exit interviews (Bharthvajan
2014).
Conducting exit
interviews are crucial to putting together better teams and boosting culture,
which ultimately plays a huge role within the overall success of your business
(Marielle 2017). In the early part of HR, exit interviews looked like a
formality just one of many components of the method of leaving a job. Employees
were particularly hesitant to give feedback, thinking about what was the
purpose of explaining what could be improved upon at employment that was
already leaving (Zoltan & David 1999). Previously exit interviews were not
conducted on a routine basis, as a result, it was considered as futile to ask
the departing employee-” Why do you go?” The employers were a lot of targeted
on obtaining the position filled as soon as possible rather than determining
how the vacancy could have been avoided (Bharthvajan 2014). however, within the
past few years, Employees/Employers each started taking within the exit
interviews seriously since organizations have currently started to realize the
significance of exit interviews (Boushey & Glynn, 2012).
As stated by Marielle, (2017)
here are the top four reasons you must conduct exit interviews: -
- Understanding & giving opportunities for worker Development:
- Get Insight into Management Issues:
- Keep up to date with Compensation and Benefits:
- Strengthen the Employer Brand:
Who Should Conduct Exit
Interviews?
The definition of exit
interview implies that exit interviews are conducted by the employer or the
management to unearth the explanations for employee turnover. (Zoltan &
David1999) within the case of an in-person exit interview, the company's representative
could also be either the functional head of the worker or somebody from the HR
department and not the employees' direct supervisor (Marielle 2017). so as to
reap the advantages of exit interviews, the organizations will rent a
full-fledged third party, a consultant or firm that makes a specialty of
conducting these sensitive interviews because most of the outgoing workers
might not prefer to offend the management at the time of leaving the
organization (Bharthvajan 2014).
How and when to Conduct
Exit Interview?
Upon being made aware of
an employees' notice of resignation, without any further delay an exit
interview meeting should be arranged by human resources (Zoltan & David,
1999). This meeting is generally should schedule at least one hour in the final
days of employment in a private meeting room (Robyn 2002). As per Robyn, (2002)
Prior to the exit interview, the human resource representative who conducted
the meeting reviews historical documents contained on the employee's file such
as performance appraisals, memos, and letters. The interview climate should be
positive and professional; the physical ambiance should be given apt most
importance (Bharthvajan 2014). The employers should avoid conducting the
interviews in public places like coffee shops or canteens where they may be
overheard by supervisors or other employees and, it is always better to conduct
them in the HR department's private office or on the premises of third party
consultant office (Bharthvajan 2014). As pointed out by Robyn, (2002) at the
interview a combination of predetermined open- and closed-ended questions to asked,
allowing the employee to respond based upon his or her knowledge and
experiences. Robyn, (2002) further says points of interest are raised the
human resource representative digs deeper to get more specific details and to
make sure to understands exactly what the employee reasons for the resignation.
The human resource representative attempts to listen and gather facts by asking
them to share both positive and negative experiences (Robyn 2002). Meetings are
almost always should be finishing on a positive and uplifting note and are always
carried out by a member of the HR department/ consultant (Bharthvajan 2014).
Boushey &Glynn,
(2012) some available types of exit interviews given below.
- In-person Exit Interviews
- Telephone Exit Interviews
- Paper and Pencil Exit Interviews
- Online Exit Interviews.
How to use the data
collected from Exit Interview?
According to Bharthvajan,
(2014) the aim of conducting exit interviews goes to be fruitful once it's
aimed toward encouraging the retention of valued employees. To accomplish the
explanation of exit interviews not only the HR department, however, everybody
from the superior management to all or any or any department heads/supervisors
ought to be concerned in the method. The exit interview is a medium that will
be used to resolve how the company is being perceived by its human resources. The
knowledge gathered through these interviews is otherwise difficult or not
possible to search out, they assist avoid costly lawsuits down the line, caused
by discontented employees. They additionally facilitate assess the key areas of
the company like pay packages, training, and development, recruitment,
infrastructure, management policies. the company can begin the method of
holding talented employees within the initial stage itself. an organization has
the liberty to make your mind up on from a range of ways offered that they
contemplate being the foremost effective fitted to their organization.
In conclusion for the
exit interview method to be an efficient management tool for reducing employee
turnover, it is very important that correct and reliable information is
gathered from outgoing workers. The exit interview is one of the effective
ways, by which the organization will retain the best, by correct serious
documentation of feedback obtained from the staff as they resign from the organization will determine and resolve key problems which will be useful in
retaining valuable human capital. A well-designed plan of exit interview has
the potential to become a valuable tool to assist retain the talented manpower
supported the qualitative proof gathered by human resource management. On the opposite hand, the responses from the commanding management are extremely very
important for improving career development practices, strengthen company culture,
and uncover different problems which will be affecting the ability to retain
workers, if the top management not conservative on the exit interview then the organization is only wasting money, human energy, and resources of the
organization.
References
Bharthvajan R.,(2014)
Exit Interviews. Engineering and Technology, 3(5), pp.12073-12075
Boushey .H., & Glynn
S. J., (2012)There Are Significant Business Costs to Replacing Employees
https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/economy/reports/2012/11/16/44464/there-are-significant-business-costs-to-replacing-employees/
Marielle L. (2017) Glass
door for Employers, 4 Reasons You Must Conduct Exit Interviews [Online]. Available
at <
https://www.glassdoor.com/employers/blog/4-reasons-you-must-conduct-exit-interviews.>.[
Accessed on 05th December 2019].
Robyn J., (2002)
Proceedings of the 12th Annual LERA Conference, The Effectiveness of Exit
Interviews in Reducing Employee Turnover [online]. Available at <
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/65f6/2bb2e11981cf338a0c310dc79dcb3251c629.pdf>.[
Accessed on 07th December 2019].
US Bureau of Labor
Statistics, USBLS (2014) global compliance. com/exit-interviews, International
Journal of Innovative Research in Science, Engineering, and Technology. USA,
USBLS.
Zoltan J. and David B.
(1999) “Innovation in Large and Small Firms: An Empirical Analysis,” American
Economic Review, 78(4), 678-690.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIt is really good article then I agree with your opinions and also change the climate of the organization by changing management style, making changes that reflect employee opinions, and creating value recognition programs where needed. It will help to understand factors behind employee turnover.
ReplyDeleteAs stated by Bharthvajan, (2014) organization will change based on the economical, political, environmental, global and technological factors, based on these changes employees should change, if not they will be outdated and redundant. As you stated by exit interview we can identify factors that needed to retain them.
DeleteEmployment is a form of slavery. This is a provocative analogy and may be offensive to some, but it is key to understanding why employees are often unhappy ( Katcher, 2007).This is very withal to get an proper understanding why an employee leaving the organization.This can occur under any reason & it is the duty of the HR or the organization management to know it.
ReplyDeleteYes. Employment has been likened to slavery for time immemorial. On numerous occasions it's been likened very heavily to chattel slavery, including by prominent philosopher Noam Chomsky. Throughout history man's desire to control others has never ceased, whether it be through slavery, serfdom, or wage slavery (Robyn 2002). As you stated understanding employee is needed and by exit interview will give that understanding how to act with future employees.
DeleteGood content Sinan. As Giacalone et al (1997) states, trying to capture information that will assist management in detecting employee problems or organizational events that may either foster or reduce employee turnover is the basic purpose of the exit interview. Reducing turnover is not the only advantage of exit interviews. Information gathered from the interviews can be compiled into a database for diagnosing organizational problems (Russo, 2000)
ReplyDeleteAs you stated by exit interview will diagnose the employee issues and employer can be facilitate assess the key areas of the company like pay packages, training, and development, recruitment, infrastructure, management policies. The company can begin the method of holding talented employees within the initial stage itself & reducing employee turnover (Bharthvajan, 2014).
DeleteGood insights on employee exit interviews and its importance, Sinnen. similarly Like a bad break up, a poor off-boarding experience can leave a bad taste in the mouth and lead to consequences in the long run that extend beyond the individual affected, so it is important to focus on best off-boarding practice too (Tulloch; 2019)
ReplyDeleteI do understand your comment, hope that in an exit interview person may give wrong comment on remaining individuals intentionally, & them also to follow time to come. Recognizing the negative impacts of the exit interview by the HR and keep remember, one of a company's key goals is employee retention, act withing the norms will not effect the outgoing individual to make an impact on to the organization (Robyn,2002).
DeleteAs stated by Neal (1989), management consider that the exit interviews are a powerful tool for human resource practitioners and researchers to monitor and analyze employee turnover. According to my opinion, through exit interviews human resource practitioners can discover what causes employee dissatisfaction, so that changes can be made and employee turnover can be reduced. The exit interview must be based upon a standardized format, assure employee confidentiality, employ talented interviewing staff, involve periodic assessment of effectiveness, and provide for routine feedback to management in order to get proper idea on employee turnover (Johus, 2001). Then the organizations can develop strategies to retain the existing employees by improving and addressing the identified key issues for higher turnover.
ReplyDeleteHi, Krishanthini, this is interesting topic in any type organization. As described by Chee (2017), employee engagement, performance management and talent management have a positive relationship in employee retention. With the development of technology and the industrial revolution, there are different types of organization in any place in the world. Thus, the employees have many choices and if they are not satisfy with the job, they leave the job. Then, talent management programs are needed to engage employees enthusiastically in their job.
ReplyDeleteVery Practical Article Sinan. But the unfortunate side of this is most of the companies do not conduct exit interviews since they are really looking for the replacement only and the companies who do the exit interviews do not count or analyze the left employee feed back, and some though they analyzed, not sharing with the senior management, and there are another though they analyzed and shared with the top management do not take necessary action.(HBR, 2016). In my personal point of view management of most companies do not see the advantage of carrying out a exit interviews.
ReplyDeleteYes Dinithi, as you stated some companies not conducting exit interview or conducted and obtained critical information not escalated to top management for decision making, this will lead to deteriorate the objective of exit interview. On the other hand departing employee may want to flow them by the exciting employees due to that departing employee will put forward fabricated and negative experiences to HR department through exit interview. HR department should be able to take the balance of information and put in to action and escalated relevant information to the top (Robyn 2002). As per the article I do wanted to highlight the importance of exit interview and make organization aware and put them in to this practice.
DeleteAlong these lines distinguishing explicit reasons with respect to why they might be deciding to leave. Numerous organizations have found that turnover is diminished essentially when issues influencing representatives are tended to quickly and expertly. Organizations attempt to decrease representative turnover rates by offering advantages, for example, paid days off, paid occasions and adaptable timetables. (Beam, 2014)
ReplyDeleteYeas Deepika, most of the highlighted points such as paid day, paid occasions, adaptable time tables, work from home, leave set off, work online are some of points that known to organization through exit interviews (Russo, 2000).
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteGood content Sinan. Gathering of accurate and reliable information is that the main important factor in an exit interview process. it acts as an efficient management tool in reducing turnover rate (Johns, 2004).
ReplyDeleteYes reducing employee turnover will be the positive impact on employee retention (Zoltan & David 1999).
DeleteIt's a good article, Lyman Watchman proposed some key developments that reverberate within billing writing today. Particularly, the hypothesis of the wishes fulfilled by Doorman and Steers (1973) states that the fulfilment of the work and the maintenance pivot in how close a job satisfies the introductory work wishes of the employees. Since then, his show has become a central hypothesis of job compliance.
ReplyDelete